Provisional Sums are common in construction contracts.
The way they are treated is not always the same.
One Contractor may allow time for Provisional Sum work in its programme. Another may allow none.
One tender may include Margin and P&G against the allowance. Another may deal with those costs differently.
Sometimes the scope sitting behind a Provisional Sum is reasonably clear at tender.
Sometimes there is little more than a dollar allowance.
These differences create ambiguity in the tenders we prepare and the contracts we sign.
Under NZS 3910, understanding a Provisional Sum starts with the age old question:
What could an experienced Contractor reasonably have anticipated, at the time of tender?
That question becomes particularly important under NZS 3910:2023.
What is a Provisional Sum?
A Provisional Sum is an allowance included in the Contract for work that may or may not later be instructed.
The final scope, quantity or detail may not be sufficiently developed at tender stage to allow the work to be fully priced.
Further, the Contractor does not automatically have the right to undertake the work simply because a Provisional Sum appears in the Contract. The work must first be instructed.
Once instructed, the value of that work is dealt with using the Variation valuation provisions.
That principle is not new.
Under NZS 3910:2013, clause 12.9.3(a) provides for work instructed against a Provisional Sum to be valued as a Variation.
NZS 3910:2023 retains that concept in clause 9.7.3.
The important change in the 2023 edition comes next.
What Changed in NZS 3910:2023?
Clause 9.7.4 introduces an additional test.
In practical terms, it asks whether the scope of the Provisional Sum work has changed from what an experienced Contractor could reasonably have anticipated when pricing the tender.
If the scope changes in a way that an experienced Contractor could not reasonably have anticipated, that change in scope shall be treated as a Variation.
There is an important distinction between work being:
valued as a Variation
and
treated as a Variation.
The first deals with how instructed Provisional Sum work is valued.
The second may introduce entitlement to an Extension of Time with costs.
This is why the tender information is so important.
Defined and Undefined Provisional Sums
NZS 3910 does not formally classify Provisional Sums as “defined” and “undefined”.
But it is a useful way to think about the risk.
A defined Provisional Sum has enough information around it for an experienced Contractor to understand the likely scope and make reasonable allowances when pricing and programming the work.
An undefined Provisional Sum has much less certainty.
The allowance may be known, but the work sitting behind it is not.
If the scope is reasonably defined at tender, the Contractor may be expected to have considered the foreseeable programme and pricing implications of that work.
If very little scope was defined, it becomes much harder to argue later that the Contractor should have anticipated the impact of work that had not yet been described.
This is exactly why Provisional Sum risk should be dealt with before the Contract is awarded.
The objective is simple.
Define the price and time risk before the work starts, rather than arguing about who owns it afterwards.
Download the free Provisional Sums guidance note document from Seven Rivers.
Learn more about our construction training.
This article provides general industry guidance and is not legal advice. The specific wording, pricing structure and risk allocation within each Contract should always be considered.

Call 0800 7 RIVERS
Email enquiries@sevenrivers.co.nz


